java.lang.IllegalStateException:尚未创建临时文件夹

java.lang.IllegalStateException:尚未创建临时文件夹,java,junit,junit-rule,Java,Junit,Junit Rule,我正在为我的用例创建一个新的@规则,如下所示 public class ActiveDirectoryConfigurationRule extends ExternalResource { @Rule public TemporaryFolder temporaryFolder = new TemporaryFolder(); public File addActiveDirectoryConfigurationToFile(ActiveDirectoryConfigurati

我正在为我的用例创建一个新的
@规则
,如下所示

public class ActiveDirectoryConfigurationRule extends ExternalResource {

  @Rule
  public TemporaryFolder temporaryFolder = new TemporaryFolder();

  public File addActiveDirectoryConfigurationToFile(ActiveDirectoryConfiguration configuration) throws IOException {
    File file = temporaryFolder.newFile();
    objectMapper.writeValue(file, configuration);
    return file;
  }

  private ObjectMapper registerJdk8ModuleAndGetObjectMapper() {
    ObjectMapper objectMapper = new ObjectMapper();
    objectMapper.registerModule(new Jdk8Module());
    return objectMapper;
  }
}
在我的
测试中
我将其用作

public class ActiveDirectoryConfigurationStoreTest {

      @Rule
      public ActiveDirectoryConfigurationRule configurationRule = new ActiveDirectoryConfigurationRule();

          @Test
          public void getWhenConfigurationExists() throws Exception {
            ActiveDirectoryConfiguration activeDirectoryConfiguration = //....;
            File configurationToFile = configurationRule.addActiveDirectoryConfigurationToFile(activeDirectoryConfiguration);

            ActiveDirectoryConfigurationStore configurationStore = new ActiveDirectoryConfigurationStore(configurationToFile);
            Optional<ActiveDirectoryConfiguration> mayBeConfiguration = configurationStore.getConfiguration();
            assertTrue(mayBeConfiguration.isPresent());
          }
        }
似乎在创建自己的
@规则
时,我无法依赖任何现有的
@规则


这就是问题所在吗?我该如何解决它呢?

是的,我认为JUnit中没有内置任何东西可以让您像现在这样“嵌套”规则对象

我认为最明显的选择是:

  • 在自定义@Rule中,在适当的时间调用子@Rule上的各种方法。(本质上,假设您是JUnit库,在每个接口上使用@Rule。)我还没有深入了解细节,看看它有多复杂
  • 让@Rule扩展
    临时文件夹
    ,而不是
    外部资源
    ,确保在覆盖的任何方法中调用
    super()
    。这让你可以“做一个
    TemporaryFolder
    做的每件事,然后做一些”,这也许不是完美的OO理论(因为它不是一种真正的TemporaryFolder),但应该按照你想要的方式工作。我在设置一个特定的文件夹时使用了这种方法,该文件夹需要为我的测试设置一个特定的环境,并且工作得相当好
  • 让您的自定义@Rule作为构造函数参数接受一个
    TemporaryFolder
    引用,然后将其保存在字段中并根据需要使用。这要求@Rule的所有用户都包含两个@Rule对象,但也许可以清楚地表明,测试确实需要一个临时文件夹来完成它的工作,以及您的特定自定义设置

  • 不支持在规则内部声明带有
    @Rule
    的规则。但您可以手动运行另一条规则

    public class ActiveDirectoryConfigurationRule implements TestRule {
    
      private TemporaryFolder temporaryFolder = new TemporaryFolder();
    
      @Override
      public Statement apply(Statement base, Description description) {
        Statement testWrappedWithYourCode = new Statement() {
          public void evaluate() {
            before();
    
            List<Throwable> errors = new ArrayList<Throwable>();
            try {
              base.evaluate();
            } catch (Throwable t) {
              errors.add(t);
            } finally {
              try {
                after();
              } catch (Throwable t) {
                errors.add(t);
              }
            }
            MultipleFailureException.assertEmpty(errors);
          }
        }
    
        return temporaryFolder.apply(testWrappedWithYourCode, description);
      }
    
      public File addActiveDirectoryConfigurationToFile(ActiveDirectoryConfiguration configuration) throws IOException {
        File file = temporaryFolder.newFile();
        objectMapper.writeValue(file, configuration);
        return file;
      }
    
      private ObjectMapper registerJdk8ModuleAndGetObjectMapper() {
        ObjectMapper objectMapper = new ObjectMapper();
        objectMapper.registerModule(new Jdk8Module());
        return objectMapper;
      }
    }
    
    公共类ActiveDirectoryConfigurationRule实现TestRule{
    private TemporaryFolder TemporaryFolder=新建TemporaryFolder();
    @凌驾
    公开声明应用(声明库、说明){
    语句testWrappedWithYourCode=new语句(){
    公共空间评估(){
    在()之前;
    列表错误=新建ArrayList();
    试一试{
    base.evaluate();
    }捕获(可丢弃的t){
    错误。添加(t);
    }最后{
    试一试{
    在()之后;
    }捕获(可丢弃的t){
    错误。添加(t);
    }
    }
    MultipleFailureException.assertEmpty(错误);
    }
    }
    返回临时文件夹.apply(testWrappedWithYourCode,description);
    }
    公共文件addActiveDirectoryConfigurationToFile(ActiveDirectoryConfiguration配置)引发IOException{
    File File=temporaryFolder.newFile();
    objectMapper.writeValue(文件、配置);
    返回文件;
    }
    私有对象映射器注册表jdk8moduleandgetObjectMapper(){
    ObjectMapper ObjectMapper=新的ObjectMapper();
    registerModule(新的Jdk8Module());
    返回对象映射器;
    }
    }
    
    Option#3听起来是最好的设计。但是,我认为这将很难实现:您希望保证先实例化了
    TemporaryFolder
    ,这样您就可以将其传递给您的自定义
    规则
    。为此,JUnit有一个
    规则链
    ()。在这里,您可以定义顺序,但不能将一个实例传递给另一个实例的构造函数。真是进退两难!我认为选项1是实用的:覆盖
    apply(…)
    ,将
    语句
    包装在
    TemporaryFolder
    生成的语句周围,并在子规则后执行逻辑。我也喜欢这种方法3,我将阅读
    规则链
    public class ActiveDirectoryConfigurationRule implements TestRule {
    
      private TemporaryFolder temporaryFolder = new TemporaryFolder();
    
      @Override
      public Statement apply(Statement base, Description description) {
        Statement testWrappedWithYourCode = new Statement() {
          public void evaluate() {
            before();
    
            List<Throwable> errors = new ArrayList<Throwable>();
            try {
              base.evaluate();
            } catch (Throwable t) {
              errors.add(t);
            } finally {
              try {
                after();
              } catch (Throwable t) {
                errors.add(t);
              }
            }
            MultipleFailureException.assertEmpty(errors);
          }
        }
    
        return temporaryFolder.apply(testWrappedWithYourCode, description);
      }
    
      public File addActiveDirectoryConfigurationToFile(ActiveDirectoryConfiguration configuration) throws IOException {
        File file = temporaryFolder.newFile();
        objectMapper.writeValue(file, configuration);
        return file;
      }
    
      private ObjectMapper registerJdk8ModuleAndGetObjectMapper() {
        ObjectMapper objectMapper = new ObjectMapper();
        objectMapper.registerModule(new Jdk8Module());
        return objectMapper;
      }
    }