Parsing Go解析器未检测到结构类型上的文档注释
我正在尝试使用Go和包读取结构类型上的关联文档注释。在本例中,代码只是将自身用作源代码Parsing Go解析器未检测到结构类型上的文档注释,parsing,go,abstract-syntax-tree,Parsing,Go,Abstract Syntax Tree,我正在尝试使用Go和包读取结构类型上的关联文档注释。在本例中,代码只是将自身用作源代码 package main import ( "fmt" "go/ast" "go/parser" "go/token" ) // FirstType docs type FirstType struct { // FirstMember docs FirstMember string } // SecondType docs type SecondType
package main
import (
"fmt"
"go/ast"
"go/parser"
"go/token"
)
// FirstType docs
type FirstType struct {
// FirstMember docs
FirstMember string
}
// SecondType docs
type SecondType struct {
// SecondMember docs
SecondMember string
}
// Main docs
func main() {
fset := token.NewFileSet() // positions are relative to fset
d, err := parser.ParseDir(fset, "./", nil, parser.ParseComments)
if err != nil {
fmt.Println(err)
return
}
for _, f := range d {
ast.Inspect(f, func(n ast.Node) bool {
switch x := n.(type) {
case *ast.FuncDecl:
fmt.Printf("%s:\tFuncDecl %s\t%s\n", fset.Position(n.Pos()), x.Name, x.Doc)
case *ast.TypeSpec:
fmt.Printf("%s:\tTypeSpec %s\t%s\n", fset.Position(n.Pos()), x.Name, x.Doc)
case *ast.Field:
fmt.Printf("%s:\tField %s\t%s\n", fset.Position(n.Pos()), x.Names, x.Doc)
}
return true
})
}
}
func和字段的注释文档输出没有问题,但由于某些原因,找不到“FirstType文档”和“SecondType文档”。我错过了什么?Go版本是1.1.2
(要运行上述操作,请将其保存到main.go文件中,然后
go run main.go
)您需要使用go/doc
包从ast提取文档:
package main
import (
"fmt"
"go/doc"
"go/parser"
"go/token"
)
// FirstType docs
type FirstType struct {
// FirstMember docs
FirstMember string
}
// SecondType docs
type SecondType struct {
// SecondMember docs
SecondMember string
}
// Main docs
func main() {
fset := token.NewFileSet() // positions are relative to fset
d, err := parser.ParseDir(fset, "./", nil, parser.ParseComments)
if err != nil {
fmt.Println(err)
return
}
for k, f := range d {
fmt.Println("package", k)
p := doc.New(f, "./", 0)
for _, t := range p.Types {
fmt.Println(" type", t.Name)
fmt.Println(" docs:", t.Doc)
}
}
}
好问题!
查看go/doc
的源代码,我们可以看到它必须在readType
函数中处理相同的情况。上面写着:
324 func (r *reader) readType(decl *ast.GenDecl, spec *ast.TypeSpec) {
...
334 // compute documentation
335 doc := spec.Doc
336 spec.Doc = nil // doc consumed - remove from AST
337 if doc == nil {
338 // no doc associated with the spec, use the declaration doc, if any
339 doc = decl.Doc
340 }
...
请特别注意它需要如何处理AST没有附加到TypeSpec的文档的情况。为此,它依赖于GenDecl
。这为我们提供了一条线索,告诉我们如何直接使用AST解析结构的文档注释。调整问题代码中的for循环,为*ast.GenDecl
添加案例:
for _, f := range d {
ast.Inspect(f, func(n ast.Node) bool {
switch x := n.(type) {
case *ast.FuncDecl:
fmt.Printf("%s:\tFuncDecl %s\t%s\n", fset.Position(n.Pos()), x.Name, x.Doc.Text())
case *ast.TypeSpec:
fmt.Printf("%s:\tTypeSpec %s\t%s\n", fset.Position(n.Pos()), x.Name, x.Doc.Text())
case *ast.Field:
fmt.Printf("%s:\tField %s\t%s\n", fset.Position(n.Pos()), x.Names, x.Doc.Text())
case *ast.GenDecl:
fmt.Printf("%s:\tGenDecl %s\n", fset.Position(n.Pos()), x.Doc.Text())
}
return true
})
}
运行此命令将为我们提供:
main.go:3:1: GenDecl %!s(*ast.CommentGroup=<nil>)
main.go:11:1: GenDecl &{[%!s(*ast.Comment=&{69 // FirstType docs})]}
main.go:11:6: TypeSpec FirstType %!s(*ast.CommentGroup=<nil>)
main.go:13:2: Field [FirstMember] &{[%!s(*ast.Comment=&{112 // FirstMember docs})]}
main.go:17:1: GenDecl &{[%!s(*ast.Comment=&{155 // SecondType docs})]}
main.go:17:6: TypeSpec SecondType %!s(*ast.CommentGroup=<nil>)
main.go:19:2: Field [SecondMember] &{[%!s(*ast.Comment=&{200 // SecondMember docs})]}
main.go:23:1: FuncDecl main &{[%!s(*ast.Comment=&{245 // Main docs})]}
main.go:33:23: Field [n] %!s(*ast.CommentGroup=<nil>)
main.go:33:35: Field [] %!s(*ast.CommentGroup=<nil>)
但为什么会这样?
假设我们稍微更改了问题中代码的类型定义(这样定义结构并不常见,但仍然有效):
运行代码(包括ast.GenDecl
的案例),我们得到:
main.go:3:1: GenDecl %!s(*ast.CommentGroup=<nil>)
main.go:11:1: GenDecl &{[%!s(*ast.Comment=&{69 // This documents FirstType and SecondType together})]}
main.go:13:2: TypeSpec FirstType &{[%!s(*ast.Comment=&{129 // FirstType docs})]}
main.go:15:3: Field [FirstMember] &{[%!s(*ast.Comment=&{169 // FirstMember docs})]}
main.go:19:2: TypeSpec SecondType &{[%!s(*ast.Comment=&{215 // SecondType docs})]}
main.go:21:3: Field [SecondMember] &{[%!s(*ast.Comment=&{257 // SecondMember docs})]}
main.go:26:1: FuncDecl main &{[%!s(*ast.Comment=&{306 // Main docs})]}
main.go:36:23: Field [n] %!s(*ast.CommentGroup=<nil>)
main.go:36:35: Field [] %!s(*ast.CommentGroup=<nil>)
因此,如果您希望使用纯AST解析注释,您需要知道这就是它的工作方式。但是@mjibson建议的首选方法是使用
go/doc
。祝你好运 尽管go/doc是一种解决方案,但这仍然不能回答为什么go/ast不提供关于类型的注释/doc(例如关于TypeSpec
)
// This documents FirstType and SecondType together
type (
// FirstType docs
FirstType struct {
// FirstMember docs
FirstMember string
}
// SecondType docs
SecondType struct {
// SecondMember docs
SecondMember string
}
)
main.go:3:1: GenDecl %!s(*ast.CommentGroup=<nil>)
main.go:11:1: GenDecl &{[%!s(*ast.Comment=&{69 // This documents FirstType and SecondType together})]}
main.go:13:2: TypeSpec FirstType &{[%!s(*ast.Comment=&{129 // FirstType docs})]}
main.go:15:3: Field [FirstMember] &{[%!s(*ast.Comment=&{169 // FirstMember docs})]}
main.go:19:2: TypeSpec SecondType &{[%!s(*ast.Comment=&{215 // SecondType docs})]}
main.go:21:3: Field [SecondMember] &{[%!s(*ast.Comment=&{257 // SecondMember docs})]}
main.go:26:1: FuncDecl main &{[%!s(*ast.Comment=&{306 // Main docs})]}
main.go:36:23: Field [n] %!s(*ast.CommentGroup=<nil>)
main.go:36:35: Field [] %!s(*ast.CommentGroup=<nil>)
// some general docs
var (
// v docs
v int
// v2 docs
v2 string
)