Java Android MVP：是否应该通知演示者所有事情？

我目前正在使用MVP架构创建我的第一个应用程序。我已经多次遇到这样的情况，视图会通知演示者一些单击事件，演示者只需在视图上调用一个方法来做一些响应。 看看这个例子：

interface ProfileView {

    /**
     * Displays the avatar photo stored at the given Uri path.
     * @param uriPath the Uri path which is pointing to the photos location
     */
    void displayAvatarPhoto(@Nullable String uriPath);

    /**
     * Sets and displays the user´s name.
     * @param name the user´s name to be displayed
     */
    void displayName(@NonNull String name);

    /**
     * Sets and displays the user´s email.
     * @param email the user´s email to be displayed
     */
    void displayEmail(@NonNull String email);

    /**
     * Sets and displays the user´s birthday date.
     * @param birthday the user´s birthday date
     */
    void displayBirthday(@NonNull String birthday);

    /**
     * Sets and displays the time when the user wants to be notified.
     * @param time the time when the user wants to be notified
     */
    void displayNotificationTime(@NonNull String time);

    void showSelectAvatarPhotoDialog();
    void showEnterNameDialog();
    void showEnterEmailDialog();
    void showEnterBirthdayDialog();
    void showSetNotificationTimeDialog();
}

interface ProfilePresenter {

    /* Lifecycle methods. */
    void onCreate();
    void onDestroy();

    /* Called when the user clicks on the corresponding views. */
    void onChangeAvatarPhoto();
    void onChangeNameClicked();
    void onChangeEmailClicked();
    void onChangeBirthdayClicked();
    void onChangeNotificationTimeClicked();

    /**
     * Called when the user wants to delete his current avatar photo.
     */
    void onDeleteAvatarPhotoClicked();

    /**
     * Called when the user has selected/made a new photo for his avatar profile.
     * @param uriPath the Uri path where the photo is stored, not null or empty
     */
    void onAvatarPhotoMade(@Nullable String uriPath);

    /**
     * Called when the user has entered a name for his avatar profile.
     * @param name the new name the user has entered, not null or empty
     */
    void onNameEntered(@NonNull String name);

    /**
     * Called when the user has entered an email for his avatar profile.
     * @param email the new email the user has entered, not null or empty
     */
    void onEmailEntered(@NonNull String email);

    /**
     * Called when the user has entered a birthday date for his avatar profile.
     * @param year the year the user was born
     * @param month the month the user was born
     * @param day the day the user was born
     */
    void onBirthdayEntered(int year, int month, int day);

    /**
     * Called when the user has toggled the notifications option.
     * @param notificationsEnabled whether or not notifications should be enabled
     */
    void onNotificationsToggled(boolean notificationsEnabled);

    /**
     * Called when the user has entered a time when he wants to be notified.
     * @param hour 0 - 23
     * @param minute
     */
    void onNotificationTimeEntered(int hour, int minute);
}

在充当视图的片段中，我设置了以下侦听器，这些侦听器将通知演示者用户单击了某个内容：

rowItemName.setOnClickListener(v -> mvpPresenter.onChangeNameClicked());
rowItemEmail.setOnClickListener(v -> mvpPresenter.onChangeEmailClicked());
rowItemBirthday.setOnClickListener(v -> mvpPresenter.onChangeBirthdayClicked());
rowItemNotificationTime.setOnClickListener(v -> mvpPresenter.onChangeNotificationTimeClicked());

然后，演示者将简单地调用视图的一个方法来告诉它要做什么：

@Override
    public void onChangeAvatarPhoto() {
        mvpView.showSelectAvatarPhotoDialog();
    }

    @Override
    public void onChangeNameClicked() {
        mvpView.showEnterNameDialog();
    }

    @Override
    public void onChangeEmailClicked() {
        mvpView.showEnterEmailDialog();
    }

    @Override
    public void onChangeBirthdayClicked() {
        mvpView.showEnterBirthdayDialog();
    }

    @Override
    public void onChangeNotificationTimeClicked() {
        mvpView.showSetNotificationTimeDialog();
    }

我的问题是：这是正确的方法（如果有），还是在这种情况下让视图直接显示本例中的对话框，而不向演示者发出“不必要”的调用更好

---

坦克很多：）

我经常遇到同样的问题，但网上有很多指向各个方向的文献。所以我想没有一个真正的答案。如果你真的想追随MVP，那么你应该做你所做的。如果你是一个理性的人，你的点击事件，只是有UI的后果，然后跳过演示者。谢谢你的回答。我已经倾向于违反MVP规则（如果有像你说的真正的规则的话），因为我看不到从这个附加的抽象层中可以得到什么好处。你的回答证实了我的想法，所以非常感谢：）编辑：错thread@Elias如果你把代码放在一个预网器中，你就可以用测试来覆盖它。此外，可能很少有业务逻辑，例如发送分析事件