Algorithm 如何设计一种计算倒计时式数学数谜的算法
我一直想这样做，但每次我开始思考这个问题时，它都会让我大吃一惊，因为它的指数性质 我希望能够理解的问题解决者和代码用于倒计时数学问题： 给定一组数字X1到X5，计算如何使用数学运算将它们组合成Y。 您可以应用乘法、除法、加法和减法 那么Algorithm 如何设计一种计算倒计时式数学数谜的算法,algorithm,combinatorics,Algorithm,Combinatorics,我一直想这样做，但每次我开始思考这个问题时，它都会让我大吃一惊，因为它的指数性质 我希望能够理解的问题解决者和代码用于倒计时数学问题： 给定一组数字X1到X5，计算如何使用数学运算将它们组合成Y。 您可以应用乘法、除法、加法和减法 那么1,3,7,6,8,3如何使348 回答：（（8*7）+3）-1）*6=348 如何编写一个算法来解决这个问题？当你试图解决这样的问题时，你从哪里开始？在设计这样一个算法时，您需要考虑哪些重要因素？当然它是指数型的，但它很小，所以一个好的（足够）简单的实现将是一个
1,3,7,6,8,3348（（8*7）+3）-1）*6=348如何编写一个算法来解决这个问题？当你试图解决这样的问题时，你从哪里开始？在设计这样一个算法时，您需要考虑哪些重要因素？当然它是指数型的，但它很小，所以一个好的（足够）简单的实现将是一个好的开始。我建议你放弃通常用括号括起来的中缀符号，使用后缀，这样更容易编程。您始终可以将输出美化为单独的阶段 首先列出并计算所有（有效）数字和运算符序列。例如（在后缀中）： 我的Java很可笑，我不是来这里被嘲笑的，所以我将把编写代码留给你 对于所有读到这篇文章的聪明人：是的，我知道即使是像这样的小问题，也有可能更快的更聪明的方法，我只是将OP指向一个初步的工作解决方案。其他人可以用更智能的解决方案写出答案 因此，要回答您的问题：
- 我从一个算法开始，我认为这个算法会很快引导我找到一个可行的解决方案。在这种情况下，（对我来说）显而易见的选择是对所有可能的计算进行详尽的列举和测试
- 如果由于性能原因，明显的算法看起来不吸引人，我将开始更深入地思考它，回顾我所知道的其他可能提供更好性能的算法。我可能会先开始编写其中一个
- 如果我坚持使用穷举算法，并且发现实际上运行时间太长，那么我可能会返回到上一步并再次编写代码。但这必须是值得的，需要进行成本/收益评估——只要我的代码能够超越Rachel Riley，我就会感到满意
- 重要的考虑因素包括我的时间和电脑时间，我的花费要高很多
- 我认为，您需要首先严格定义问题。你可以做什么，不可以做什么。你可以从简单开始，只允许乘法、除法、减法和加法
现在您知道了您的问题空间—输入集、可用操作集和所需输入。如果只有4个操作和x个输入，则组合的数量少于：
可以执行操作的顺序数（x！）乘以每个步骤上可能选择的操作数：4^x。如您所见，对于6个数字，它给出了合理的2949120操作。这意味着这可能是暴力算法的限制
一旦你有了蛮力，并且你知道它是有效的，你就可以开始用一些需要你定义启发式函数的方法来改进你的算法
在我看来，思考这个问题的最佳方式是搜索问题。主要的困难是找到好的启发式方法，或者减少问题空间的方法（如果你的数字与答案相加不一致，你至少需要一次乘法等）。从小事做起，在这基础上，一旦你有了一些代码，就要问后续问题。输入显然是一组数字和运算符：D={1,3,3,6,7,8,3}和Op={+，-，*，/}。最直接的算法将是一个解算器，它可以处理这些集合的所有可能组合。其中集合Op的元素可以根据需要经常使用，但集合D中的元素只使用一次。伪代码：
D={1,3,3,6,7,8,3}
Op={+,-,*,/}
Solution=348
for each permutation D_ of D:
for each binary tree T with D_ as its leafs:
for each sequence of operators Op_ from Op with length |D_|-1:
label each inner tree node with operators from Op_
result = compute T using infix traversal
if result==Solution
return T
return nil
除此之外：请阅读jedrus07和HPM的答案。非常快速且肮脏的Java解决方案：
public class JavaApplication1
{
public static void main(String[] args)
{
List<Integer> list = Arrays.asList(1, 3, 7, 6, 8, 3);
for (Integer integer : list) {
List<Integer> runList = new ArrayList<>(list);
runList.remove(integer);
Result result = getOperations(runList, integer, 348);
if (result.success) {
System.out.println(integer + result.output);
return;
}
}
}
public static class Result
{
public String output;
public boolean success;
}
public static Result getOperations(List<Integer> numbers, int midNumber, int target)
{
Result midResult = new Result();
if (midNumber == target) {
midResult.success = true;
midResult.output = "";
return midResult;
}
for (Integer number : numbers) {
List<Integer> newList = new ArrayList<Integer>(numbers);
newList.remove(number);
if (newList.isEmpty()) {
if (midNumber - number == target) {
midResult.success = true;
midResult.output = "-" + number;
return midResult;
}
if (midNumber + number == target) {
midResult.success = true;
midResult.output = "+" + number;
return midResult;
}
if (midNumber * number == target) {
midResult.success = true;
midResult.output = "*" + number;
return midResult;
}
if (midNumber / number == target) {
midResult.success = true;
midResult.output = "/" + number;
return midResult;
}
midResult.success = false;
midResult.output = "f" + number;
return midResult;
} else {
midResult = getOperations(newList, midNumber - number, target);
if (midResult.success) {
midResult.output = "-" + number + midResult.output;
return midResult;
}
midResult = getOperations(newList, midNumber + number, target);
if (midResult.success) {
midResult.output = "+" + number + midResult.output;
return midResult;
}
midResult = getOperations(newList, midNumber * number, target);
if (midResult.success) {
midResult.output = "*" + number + midResult.output;
return midResult;
}
midResult = getOperations(newList, midNumber / number, target);
if (midResult.success) {
midResult.output = "/" + number + midResult.output;
return midResult
}
}
}
return midResult;
}
}
公共类JavaApplication1
{
公共静态void main（字符串[]args）
{
List=Arrays.asList（1,3,7,6,8,3）；
用于（整数：列表）{
List runList=newarraylist（List）；
删除（整数）；
结果=getOperations（运行列表，整数，348）；
如果（结果、成功）{
System.out.println（整数+结果输出）；
返回；
}
}
}
公共静态类结果
{
公共字符串输出；
公众的成功；
}
公共静态结果getOperations（列表编号、整数中间编号、整数目标）
{
结果midResult=新结果（）；
如果（中间数==目标）{
middresult.success=true；
midsult.output=“”；
返回中间结果；
}
for（整数：数字）{
List newList=新阵列列表（编号）；
新列表。删除（编号）；
if（newList.isEmpty（））{
if（中间编号-编号==目标）{
middresult.success=true；
midResult.output=“-”+数字；
返回中间结果；
}
如果（中间数+数字==目标）{
middresult.success=true；
midResult.output=“+”+数字；
返回中间结果；
}
如果（中间编号*编号==目标）{
middresult.success=true；
midResult.output=“*”+数字；
返回中间结果；
}
if（中间编号/编号==目标）{
middresult.success=true；
midResult.output=“/”+数字；
返回中间结果；
}
米德尔
public class JavaApplication1
{
public static void main(String[] args)
{
List<Integer> list = Arrays.asList(1, 3, 7, 6, 8, 3);
for (Integer integer : list) {
List<Integer> runList = new ArrayList<>(list);
runList.remove(integer);
Result result = getOperations(runList, integer, 348);
if (result.success) {
System.out.println(integer + result.output);
return;
}
}
}
public static class Result
{
public String output;
public boolean success;
}
public static Result getOperations(List<Integer> numbers, int midNumber, int target)
{
Result midResult = new Result();
if (midNumber == target) {
midResult.success = true;
midResult.output = "";
return midResult;
}
for (Integer number : numbers) {
List<Integer> newList = new ArrayList<Integer>(numbers);
newList.remove(number);
if (newList.isEmpty()) {
if (midNumber - number == target) {
midResult.success = true;
midResult.output = "-" + number;
return midResult;
}
if (midNumber + number == target) {
midResult.success = true;
midResult.output = "+" + number;
return midResult;
}
if (midNumber * number == target) {
midResult.success = true;
midResult.output = "*" + number;
return midResult;
}
if (midNumber / number == target) {
midResult.success = true;
midResult.output = "/" + number;
return midResult;
}
midResult.success = false;
midResult.output = "f" + number;
return midResult;
} else {
midResult = getOperations(newList, midNumber - number, target);
if (midResult.success) {
midResult.output = "-" + number + midResult.output;
return midResult;
}
midResult = getOperations(newList, midNumber + number, target);
if (midResult.success) {
midResult.output = "+" + number + midResult.output;
return midResult;
}
midResult = getOperations(newList, midNumber * number, target);
if (midResult.success) {
midResult.output = "*" + number + midResult.output;
return midResult;
}
midResult = getOperations(newList, midNumber / number, target);
if (midResult.success) {
midResult.output = "/" + number + midResult.output;
return midResult
}
}
}
return midResult;
}
}
#include <iostream>
#include <vector>
#include <algorithm>
#include <stack>
#include <iterator>
#include <string>
namespace {
enum class Op {
Add,
Sub,
Mul,
Div,
};
const std::size_t NumOps = static_cast<std::size_t>(Op::Div) + 1;
const Op FirstOp = Op::Add;
using Number = int;
class Evaluator {
std::vector<Number> values_; // stores our digits/number we can use
std::vector<Op> ops_; // stores the operators
std::vector<char> selector_; // used to select digit (0) or operator (1) when evaluating. should be std::vector<bool>, but that's broken
template <typename T>
using Stack = std::stack<T, std::vector<T>>;
// checks if a given number/operator order can be evaluated or not
bool isSelectorValid() const {
int numValues = 0;
for (auto s : selector_) {
if (s) {
if (--numValues <= 0) {
return false;
}
}
else {
++numValues;
}
}
return (numValues == 1);
}
// evaluates the current values_ and ops_ based on selector_
Number eval(Stack<Number> &stack) const {
auto vi = values_.cbegin();
auto oi = ops_.cbegin();
for (auto s : selector_) {
if (!s) {
stack.push(*(vi++));
continue;
}
Number top = stack.top();
stack.pop();
switch (*(oi++)) {
case Op::Add:
stack.top() += top;
break;
case Op::Sub:
stack.top() -= top;
break;
case Op::Mul:
stack.top() *= top;
break;
case Op::Div:
if (top == 0) {
return std::numeric_limits<Number>::max();
}
Number res = stack.top() / top;
if (res * top != stack.top()) {
return std::numeric_limits<Number>::max();
}
stack.top() = res;
break;
}
}
Number res = stack.top();
stack.pop();
return res;
}
bool nextValuesPermutation() {
return std::next_permutation(values_.begin(), values_.end());
}
bool nextOps() {
for (auto i = ops_.rbegin(), end = ops_.rend(); i != end; ++i) {
std::size_t next = static_cast<std::size_t>(*i) + 1;
if (next < NumOps) {
*i = static_cast<Op>(next);
return true;
}
*i = FirstOp;
}
return false;
}
bool nextSelectorPermutation() {
// the start permutation is always valid
do {
if (!std::next_permutation(selector_.begin(), selector_.end())) {
return false;
}
} while (!isSelectorValid());
return true;
}
static std::string buildExpr(const std::string& left, char op, const std::string &right) {
return std::string("(") + left + ' ' + op + ' ' + right + ')';
}
std::string toString() const {
Stack<std::string> stack;
auto vi = values_.cbegin();
auto oi = ops_.cbegin();
for (auto s : selector_) {
if (!s) {
stack.push(std::to_string(*(vi++)));
continue;
}
std::string top = stack.top();
stack.pop();
switch (*(oi++)) {
case Op::Add:
stack.top() = buildExpr(stack.top(), '+', top);
break;
case Op::Sub:
stack.top() = buildExpr(stack.top(), '-', top);
break;
case Op::Mul:
stack.top() = buildExpr(stack.top(), '*', top);
break;
case Op::Div:
stack.top() = buildExpr(stack.top(), '/', top);
break;
}
}
return stack.top();
}
public:
Evaluator(const std::vector<Number>& values) :
values_(values),
ops_(values.size() - 1, FirstOp),
selector_(2 * values.size() - 1, 0) {
std::fill(selector_.begin() + values_.size(), selector_.end(), 1);
std::sort(values_.begin(), values_.end());
}
// check for solutions
// 1) we create valid permutations of our selector_ array (eg: "1 1 + 1 +",
// "1 1 1 + +", but skip "1 + 1 1 +" as that cannot be evaluated
// 2) for each evaluation order, we permutate our values
// 3) for each value permutation we check with each combination of
// operators
//
// In the first version I used a local stack in eval() (see toString()) but
// it turned out to be a performance bottleneck, so now I use a cached
// stack. Reusing the stack gives an order of magnitude speed-up (from
// 4.3sec to 0.7sec) due to avoiding repeated allocations. Using
// std::vector as a backing store also gives a slight performance boost
// over the default std::deque.
std::size_t check(Number target, bool singleResult = false) {
Stack<Number> stack;
std::size_t res = 0;
do {
do {
do {
Number value = eval(stack);
if (value == target) {
++res;
std::cout << target << " = " << toString() << "\n";
if (singleResult) {
return res;
}
}
} while (nextOps());
} while (nextValuesPermutation());
} while (nextSelectorPermutation());
return res;
}
};
} // namespace
int main(int argc, const char **argv) {
int i = 1;
bool singleResult = false;
if (argc > 1 && std::string("-s") == argv[1]) {
singleResult = true;
++i;
}
if (argc < i + 2) {
std::cerr << argv[0] << " [-s] <target> <digit>[ <digit>]...\n";
std::exit(1);
}
Number target = std::stoi(argv[i]);
std::vector<Number> values;
while (++i < argc) {
values.push_back(std::stoi(argv[i]));
}
Evaluator evaluator{values};
std::size_t res = evaluator.check(target, singleResult);
if (!singleResult) {
std::cout << "Number of solutions: " << res << "\n";
}
return 0;
}
#!/usr/bin/env python3
import sys
from itertools import combinations, product, zip_longest
from functools import lru_cache
assert sys.version_info >= (3, 6)
class Solutions:
def __init__(self, numbers):
self.all_numbers = numbers
self.size = len(numbers)
self.all_groups = self.unique_groups()
def unique_groups(self):
all_groups = {}
all_numbers, size = self.all_numbers, self.size
for m in range(1, size+1):
for numbers in combinations(all_numbers, m):
if numbers in all_groups:
continue
all_groups[numbers] = Group(numbers, all_groups)
return all_groups
def walk(self):
for group in self.all_groups.values():
yield from group.calculations
class Group:
def __init__(self, numbers, all_groups):
self.numbers = numbers
self.size = len(numbers)
self.partitions = list(self.partition_into_unique_pairs(all_groups))
self.calculations = list(self.perform_calculations())
def __repr__(self):
return str(self.numbers)
def partition_into_unique_pairs(self, all_groups):
# The pairs are unordered: a pair (a, b) is equivalent to (b, a).
# Therefore, for pairs of equal length only half of all combinations
# need to be generated to obtain all pairs; this is set by the limit.
if self.size == 1:
return
numbers, size = self.numbers, self.size
limits = (self.halfbinom(size, size//2), )
unique_numbers = set()
for m, limit in zip_longest(range((size+1)//2, size), limits):
for numbers1, numbers2 in self.paired_combinations(numbers, m, limit):
if numbers1 in unique_numbers:
continue
unique_numbers.add(numbers1)
group1, group2 = all_groups[numbers1], all_groups[numbers2]
yield (group1, group2)
def perform_calculations(self):
if self.size == 1:
yield Calculation.singleton(self.numbers[0])
return
for group1, group2 in self.partitions:
for calc1, calc2 in product(group1.calculations, group2.calculations):
yield from Calculation.generate(calc1, calc2)
@classmethod
def paired_combinations(cls, numbers, m, limit):
for cnt, numbers1 in enumerate(combinations(numbers, m), 1):
numbers2 = tuple(cls.filtering(numbers, numbers1))
yield (numbers1, numbers2)
if cnt == limit:
return
@staticmethod
def filtering(iterable, elements):
# filter elements out of an iterable, return the remaining elements
elems = iter(elements)
k = next(elems, None)
for n in iterable:
if n == k:
k = next(elems, None)
else:
yield n
@staticmethod
@lru_cache()
def halfbinom(n, k):
if n % 2 == 1:
return None
prod = 1
for m, l in zip(reversed(range(n+1-k, n+1)), range(1, k+1)):
prod = (prod*m)//l
return prod//2
class Calculation:
def __init__(self, expression, result, is_singleton=False):
self.expr = expression
self.result = result
self.is_singleton = is_singleton
def __repr__(self):
return self.expr
@classmethod
def singleton(cls, n):
return cls(f"{n}", n, is_singleton=True)
@classmethod
def generate(cls, calca, calcb):
if calca.result < calcb.result:
calca, calcb = calcb, calca
for result, op in cls.operations(calca.result, calcb.result):
expr1 = f"{calca.expr}" if calca.is_singleton else f"({calca.expr})"
expr2 = f"{calcb.expr}" if calcb.is_singleton else f"({calcb.expr})"
yield cls(f"{expr1} {op} {expr2}", result)
@staticmethod
def operations(x, y):
yield (x + y, '+')
if x > y: # exclude non-positive results
yield (x - y, '-')
if y > 1 and x > 1: # exclude trivial results
yield (x * y, 'x')
if y > 1 and x % y == 0: # exclude trivial and non-integer results
yield (x // y, '/')
def countdown_solver():
# input: target and numbers. If you want to play with more or less than
# 6 numbers, use the second version of 'unsorted_numbers'.
try:
target = int(sys.argv[1])
unsorted_numbers = (int(sys.argv[n+2]) for n in range(6)) # for 6 numbers
# unsorted_numbers = (int(n) for n in sys.argv[2:]) # for any numbers
numbers = tuple(sorted(unsorted_numbers, reverse=True))
except (IndexError, ValueError):
print("You must provide a target and numbers!")
return
solutions = Solutions(numbers)
smallest_difference = target
bestresults = []
for calculation in solutions.walk():
diff = abs(calculation.result - target)
if diff <= smallest_difference:
if diff < smallest_difference:
bestresults = [calculation]
smallest_difference = diff
else:
bestresults.append(calculation)
output(target, smallest_difference, bestresults)
def output(target, diff, results):
print(f"\nThe closest results differ from {target} by {diff}. They are:\n")
for calculation in results:
print(f"{calculation.result} = {calculation.expr}")
if __name__ == "__main__":
countdown_solver()
comps[m] = 4*sum(binom(m, k)*comps[k]*comps[m-k]//(1 + (2*k)//m) for k in range(1, m//2+1))
total = sum(binom(n, m)*comps[m] for m in range(1, n+1))
import sys
def driver():
try:
target = int(sys.argv[1])
nums = list((int(sys.argv[i+2]) for i in range(6)))
except (IndexError, ValueError):
print("Provide a list of 7 numbers")
return
solutions = list()
solve(target, nums, list(), solutions)
unique = set()
final = list()
for s in solutions:
a = '-'.join(sorted(s))
if not a in unique:
unique.add(a)
final.append(s)
for s in final: #print them out
print(s)
def solve(target, nums, path, solutions):
if len(nums) == 1:
return
distinct = sorted(list(set(nums)), reverse = True)
rem1 = list(distinct)
for n1 in distinct: #reduce list by combining a pair
rem1.remove(n1)
for n2 in rem1:
rem2 = list(nums) # in case of duplicates we need to start with full list and take out the n1,n2 pair of elements
rem2.remove(n1)
rem2.remove(n2)
combine(target, solutions, path, rem2, n1, n2, '+')
combine(target, solutions, path, rem2, n1, n2, '-')
if n2 > 1:
combine(target, solutions, path, rem2, n1, n2, '*')
if not n1 % n2:
combine(target, solutions, path, rem2, n1, n2, '//')
def combine(target, solutions, path, rem2, n1, n2, symb):
lst = list(rem2)
ans = eval("{0}{2}{1}".format(n1, n2, symb))
newpath = path + ["{0}{3}{1}={2}".format(n1, n2, ans, symb[0])]
if ans == target:
solutions += [newpath]
else:
lst.append(ans)
solve(target, lst, newpath, solutions)
if __name__ == "__main__":
driver()