MySQL左外连接故障

以下是按pricepoint按小时对交易进行分组的查询：

SELECT hour(Stamp) AS hour, PointID AS pricepoint, count(1) AS counter
FROM Transactions
GROUP BY 1,2;

样本输出：

+------+------------+---------+
| hour | pricepoint | counter |
+------+------------+---------+
|    0 |         19 |       5 |
|    0 |         20 |      14 |
|    1 |         19 |       3 |
|    1 |         20 |      12 |
|    2 |         19 |       2 |
|    2 |         20 |       8 |
|    3 |         19 |       2 |
|    3 |         20 |       4 |
|    4 |         19 |       1 |
|    4 |         20 |       1 |
|    5 |         19 |       4 |
|    5 |         20 |       1 |
|    6 |         20 |       2 |
|    8 |         19 |       1 |
|    8 |         20 |       4 |
|    9 |         19 |       2 |
|    9 |         20 |       5 |
|   10 |         19 |       6 |
|   10 |         20 |       1 |
|   11 |         19 |      10 |
|   11 |         20 |       2 |
|   12 |         19 |      10 |
|   12 |         20 |       3 |
|   13 |         19 |      10 |
|   13 |         20 |      10 |
|   14 |         19 |       8 |
|   14 |         20 |       3 |
|   15 |         19 |       6 |
|   15 |         20 |       8 |
|   16 |         19 |      11 |
|   16 |         20 |      10 |
|   17 |         19 |       7 |
|   17 |         20 |      17 |
|   18 |         19 |       7 |
|   18 |         20 |       9 |
|   19 |         19 |      10 |
|   19 |         20 |      12 |
|   20 |         19 |      17 |
|   20 |         20 |      11 |
|   21 |         19 |      12 |
|   21 |         20 |      29 |
|   22 |         19 |       6 |
|   22 |         20 |      21 |
|   23 |         19 |       9 |
|   23 |         20 |      23 |
+------+------------+---------+

如您所见，有些小时没有交易（例如上午7点），有些小时只有单个pricepoint的交易（例如上午6点，只有pricepoint 20，但pricepoint 19没有交易）

我希望在没有事务时显示结果集“0”，而不是像现在这样不存在

尝试使用左外连接。inHour表中的包含值0..23

SELECT H.hour, PointID AS Pricepoint, COALESCE(T.counter, 0) AS Count
FROM inHour H
LEFT OUTER JOIN
(
 SELECT hour(Stamp) AS Hour, PointID, count(1) AS counter
 FROM Transactions
 GROUP BY 1,2
 ) T
ON T.Hour = H.hour;

这将生成以下输出（为简洁起见，已截断）：

事实上，我想要的是：

|    5 |         19 |     4 |
|    5 |         20 |     1 |
|    6 |         19 |     0 |
|    6 |         20 |     2 |
|    7 |         19 |     0 |
|    7 |         20 |     0 |
|    8 |         19 |     1 |
|    8 |         20 |     4 |

在我想要的输出中，值“0”放在给定时间内没有交易的pricepoints旁边

欢迎您的建议！谢谢

SELECT h.Hour, p.Pricepoint, COUNT(t.*) AS Count
FROM inHour h,
(SELECT DISTINCT PointId AS Pricepoint FROM Transactions) p
LEFT OUTER JOIN Transactions t
ON h.Hour = hour(t.Stamp) AND p.Pricepoint = t.PointID
GROUP BY h.Hour, p.Pricepoint
ORDER BY h.Hour, p.Pricepoint

---

我现在没有时间尝试这个，所以如果它不起作用，请告诉我，我会尝试调整。

可能有人有比这个更好的解决方案，但我会使用联合来简化事情：

SELECT hour(Stamp) AS hour, PointID AS pricepoint, count(1) AS counter
FROM Transactions
GROUP BY 1,2

UNION

SELECT hour,0 AS pricepoint,0 AS counter FROM inHour WHERE hour NOT IN (SELECT hour(Stamp) FROM Transactions)

---

也许在选择所有不同价格点的子选择上左连接？否则，我会使用一个价格点的维度表。事实上，这就是我最终所做的，受Andrew的回答启发。感谢Andrew，这真的启发了我，并且我能够使用您的示例使其工作。

SELECT hour(Stamp) AS hour, PointID AS pricepoint, count(1) AS counter
FROM Transactions
GROUP BY 1,2

UNION

SELECT hour,0 AS pricepoint,0 AS counter FROM inHour WHERE hour NOT IN (SELECT hour(Stamp) FROM Transactions)